Blog

Holding our feet to the climate fire

A draft sermon for Sunday August 14th

Isaiah 5:1-7

Let me sing for my beloved my love-song concerning his vineyard: My beloved had a vineyard on a very fertile hill. He dug it and cleared it of stones, and planted it with choice vines; he built a watchtower in the midst of it, and hewed out a wine vat in it; he expected it to yield grapes, but it yielded wild grapes. And now, inhabitants of Jerusalem and people of Judah, judge between me and my vineyard. What more was there to do for my vineyard that I have not done in it? When I expected it to yield grapes, why did it yield wild grapes? And now I will tell you what I will do to my vineyard. I will remove its hedge, and it shall be devoured; I will break down its wall,
and it shall be trampled down. I will make it a waste; it shall not be pruned or hoed,  and it shall be overgrown with briers and thorns; I will also command the clouds
that they rain no rain upon it. For the vineyard of the Lord of hosts is the house of Israel, and the people of Judah are his pleasant planting; he expected justice,
but saw bloodshed; righteousness, but heard a cry!

The Gospel

Luke 12:49-56

Jesus said, “I came to bring fire to the earth, and how I wish it were already kindled! I have a baptism with which to be baptised, and what stress I am under until it is completed! 

Do you think that I have come to bring peace to the earth? No, I tell you, but rather division! From now on five in one household will be divided, three against two and two against three; they will be divided: father against son and son against father, mother against daughter and daughter against mother, mother-in-law against her daughter-in-law and daughter-in-law against mother-in-law.”He also said to the crowds, “When you see a cloud rising in the west, you immediately say, `It is going to rain’; and so it happens. And when you see the south wind blowing, you say, `There will be scorching heat’; and it happens. You hypocrites! You know how to interpret the appearance of earth and sky, but why do you not know how to interpret the present time?”

==================================================

We are, I pray, and  the EcoCongregation movements have contributed to this, now some small  distance beyond the time when members of churches, could attend a meeting on zero-waste, circular economy, the switch from fossil fuels to sustainable investment, or anything else environmental, and people would say:

 ‘Oh, you’re the church? Nice to see you, but what are you doing here?”  I’ve heard that, but thank God, it’s a while now.

That  bizarre attitude – which nonetheless has been encouraged, at times, by the churches – of   “What has the church got to do with what God has made?” [Genesis 1:1]

Which ought to be strange:  not only because of  the very ambitious aspiration  that churches might be  Net-Zero  in prayer work  and worship  just a few years from now….  

And , if  that’s  going to happen, it will need to be a positive response of faith, rather than a reluctant surrender to  secular box-ticking; … 

Not only that,  but for any church not to be passionately and urgently committed to “Care of Creation” [Genesis 2:15] is really really odd, because ours is a faith founded on God’s choice to be one with Creation; to feel in the flesh what it’s like to share, down to to a cellular level with everything that has breath,  the pull of the Earth; to wake up each day to the wonders of the heavens.  The Word became…. Flesh. [John 1:14]

The vocabulary was there, of course, to say in John’s Gospel, that the Word became, with a significant exclusiveness, human flesh, but that writer made the choice of  an inclusive way, reminding us of God’s Rainbow Covenant not just with Noah,  but with All Flesh; with the Earth.  [Genesis 9:9-11 & 13]

 Sharper focus can be quite brutal.  

A couple of centuries later, the historic creeds of the Church delighted in the humanity of Christ,  but some then  got carried away [cf some writings of Augustine] and devised ways of viewing women as derivative and inferior beings, with the injustice which unsurprisingly followed. 

Like greenhouse gas emissions – and CO2 sticks around for centuries – injustice takes a lot of cleaning up after!

In the Gender Day at COP  [‘the 26th Conference of the Parties to the intergovernmental framework Convention on Climate Change’ ] last year, that is, at the United Nations Climate conference in Glasgow, which I was able to  attend,  the objective case was compellingly made, that the education and empowerment of women is one of the most powerful measures for cutting down global human impact on the life of the planet. 

We now have solid evidence that only justice is green.  That the transition which lies ahead of us is a must, but that transition must be just.  [See, for instance,  anything to do with the Just Transition Commission set up by the Scottish govt.]

These are the signs of our times.  The things that for Jesus, only a fool would ignore.  And God doesn’t protect against chosen foolishness. [e.g. cf Matthew 7:24-27 ]

 We’re in a time when our spiritual  pendulum needs to swing in the direction of the shared earthiness of Jesus, and all that opens up,  whilst still valuing the reality of specifics. Of every sparrow that falls.  Of the drowning of a poor woman called Nonhlanhla in Durban, in floods caused to be more frequent by  fossil fuel burning, as our recent heatwave is made worse by that same cause.  [example cited by Rev Dr Rachel Mash of Southern African Anglican churches ]

Now therefore – just as we value every  prayer of words or thought – now is the time to value the embodied prayer of every small commitment or change of mind in the face of the warnings – those signs of the times [in our reading today Luke 12:cf vv 54-56] – with which God out of love has confronted us, both in our daily experience and in the prophetic voice of the suffering Earth, interpreted for us by the disciplined honesty of science.  

Now is the time  to be “kindled”,  in a way which might seem novel for a civilisation dominated by the violent power that comes with money and scale, of the neglected and despised voices, of the Earth, and of the wisdom of those still surviving indigenous humans. These peoples who care for most of the biodiversity even more vital to our survival than a balanced climate, though of course they are linked. 

Those who live close to the Earth speak the same experiential, relational  language as the Bible writers.  We should not despise either.

For every local church, there remains, if we are to ‘have life and have it in abundance’[John 10:10], a need for discerning choices, as to what, in our prayer and life and work, we take and what we leave. All the more as we have before us the spectrum of all the slants, biases and directions of interpretation to which the Holy Spirit has led us through the centuries.  

Theses ways inspired,  in the face of particular crises, to recycle the spirit and the Scriptures which themselves arose in times of trial.  

And in Jesus’ own crisis-driven words today,  [“what stress I am under”] we glimpse the context and value of those Gospels:  full or urgency, full of warnings to recycle for this day, this place, this age.   The transformation, the recycling and refertilising power of fire, as it’s been used in the management of land over millennia. [“to bring fire to the Earth”]

Not the sick, twisted, unbridled wildfires overtaking so many places on earth, but an emergency.  Which will test the nature of how well we love our friends, neighbours… fathers sons, mothers, daughters,  in-laws and more.  [Luke 12:53] 

Whom do we love well enough to stand up to them because we can see the harm they are doing?  

Whom do you love well  enough to ask if they’d thought of walking rather than driving to the post-box? Of taking the train rather than flying to a meeting in mainland UK? Of eating less meat?

When I’m gathering material for the Season of Creation, which involves asking people whose views I respect to spend time thinking and writing for riches in heaven, [Matthew 6:20]

 I know I have a limited “budget of irritation”.  

And yet, in terms which cannot but speak to us directly of climate and weather and the groaning of Creation,  Jesus insists we be prepared to cash in and max out that budget.  Out of love.  [Luke 12:53] . Because what else is Jesus about?  

But “my country or my church or my family right or wrong” is an attitude which, without spiritual discernment, leads to the destruction of that country, church or family, and the world of life to whom God has gifted this habitat we share.  [cf e.g. Job 38: 5-8 ] 

We have no time to waste worrying about how or ancestors got it right or wrong.  At times they may have been completely on target!  Frequently,  it’s  hymns and prayers of previous centuries, which were untroubled by recognising  feelings and personalities of Creation, which do the job.  The antiquated language of King James does not, like the Good News Bible,  presume that when the Greek talks of ‘every creature’  [Mark 16:15 ] it must be ‘correctively diminished’ to  “all people”.   Though of course, ‘every creature’ includes all people. 

Look online at the widely differing approaches to translating the Bible, even into English, and realise that we only ever receive the Bible in a community of interpretation, where some voices, for a while, are dominant,  but no voice is definitive for all situations. 

One Word of God,  interpreted through the Spirit, but not one version of the Bible, fits all.

So, urgently, “What is the Spirit saying to the churches today?

As EcoChaplain, I’m not restricted in the scope of my work with Christian congregations to the “bit at the beginning”  [Genesis 1-9]  and the “bit at the end”  [e.g. Revelation 21:1-3]  of the Bible.  For  that sharing of our life, and therefore of Jesus’ life with “Life writ large” is so magnificently, mind-stretchingly  broad.  

Trees, in their own way, breathe: we couldn’t if they didn’t.  

And as science has more recently reaffirmed, trees ‘talk’  [cf Isaiah 55:12]  and given the chance, care for their own. The mountains, in their own timescale, and not just in earthquakes  [Psalm  114]  certainly dance. Those of us who have cared for non-human creatures, be they plants in a vineyard or cats and dogs at home,  know of their thoughts and feelings after their own fashion: such ‘sentiment’ is God’s gift, rather than something to be ashamed of.  

All the more because love is the difference we bring into any situation.   [cf 1 John 4 7ff ]  Love is why the Church is involved.  Love is why we contribute reconciliation and transformation of conflicts where others prefer blame-games and revenge.   [cf Romans 12:19] Which are luxuries we can afford less than ever, the more we become aware of the complete connectedness of all the Earth.  

Into the worries and fears and desperation about the state of the planet, we bring  the proclamation that this is the world God so loved that God gave of Godself that which was most beloved,  that those who hope and trust might not be lost.   [John 3:16] 

And binding the Old and New Testaments together,  this is reinforced by the insight that the sabbath, and the jubilee, those times of rest and recovery and celebration, were for the land and the wildlife as for the people.   [cf Leviticus 25:6] Though of course, they also are for the people.

But that’s also one of the mysteries; how western and global north capitalist culture has bullied Christianity into a forgetfulness that what we see when we step outside and look up is not only sky, but also that the birds make sky heaven.  [Mentioned many times in OT]   How an archbishop can share a post on social media that talks of the sky as if it were a neutral dumping-ground, rather than the medium of the Word of God which comes down with the rain and snow, side by side with the equally life-giving water cycle to do the job, before the next cycle?  [cf Isaiah 55:8-13] 

The poetry of Scripture – all the way through – quite rightly and wonderfully blurs the lines – between the actions of the creator and their outcomes in Creation.  Do not ever be embarrassed or ashamed when confronted by the beauty of a mountain or a sunset or a blade of grass, by a robin or a puffin, to say ‘O  my God…’  And whatever, as a church, you actually ‘do’ – insulation, changing lighting, cutting down waste,  getting rid of plastics, tending your grounds for wildlife rather than tidiness – make sure you go for the “low-hanging fruit” : the easy enjoyable stuff first as the first steps so that they won’t be the last steps, so that joy will sustain you.

What is never said in scripture – in fact rather to the contrary – is that human beings have neither the calling nor the capacity for good or ill, to intervene in these fruitful cycles. 

We are part of them, from Adam on, that name which means ‘the Soil’. We have, and with close to 8 billion of us, it can’t be discounted, a place and purpose.  To nurture protect, enhance – or disrupt  this whole great family of the living Earth.  

And as with  that  garden  prepared for the Beloved,  which in the God’s love-song of Isaiah  referred initially to  Israel,  injustice always has environmental impact [cf Jeremiah 2:7] . Whether in terms of neglect or the toxicity of pride and greed, those thromboses in the circulation of the goodness of Creation.   Human injustice hurts every fellow creature whom God gives life.  

If nothing else, next time you speak a prayer or sing a hymn which mentions the Earth, try thinking “who” rather than “it”. Or spell Earth always with a capital letter, as you would the name of a beloved relative. See what difference it makes to your thinking.  

That’s what that churchy word ‘repentance’  [“meta-noia” = change of mind]  needs to mean. Not just saying “sorry”, but choosing to change the way you think, when you’ve recognised the harm which your previous thought led you into,

Whatever else we choose to understand by that word ‘heaven’, we’re not taking the atheist science fiction route of a mysterious and separate dimension.  Many many times, God is referred to as Maker – and in Scots, perhaps we might say Makar that word for the Poet of poets – of heaven and Earth, of Sky and soil both.  In Christ, it all holds together.   [Col 1:17] 

Season of Creation 2022: Major Reflections (for download)- Sermon-slot material for online worship:

This is a Season in itself, created during a retreat experience, staying at Loch Ossian Hostel, on Rannoch Moor (only accessible by train). Expect to be challenged.

Week 1: Choosing Life: [13 mins 50] available for Download in up to 4k.

Heeding warnings …. NB Includes one shot of a dead bird.

Week 2: Honour the Lost [12 mins 56 ] available for download in up to 1080p [4k from mid August]… Who is lost, who is not, and do we listen to the voice of God in those we have marginalised and despised?

Week 3 : Jesus blunt and wild

Week 4 : Net Zero Life . NB: some consideration of death and bereavement, including one shot of a funeral.

Week 5: Roots in the Earth, Roots in the Church

Faith communities’ open letter to COP26 President

Scottish faith communities call on COP26 President to honour Glasgow Pact commitments

Eco-Congregation Scotland chairperson Richard Murray is among diverse faith leaders and groups calling on COP26 President Alok Sharma to honour the Glasgow Pact commitments.

The Pact includes commitments from 197 nations to build resilience to climate change, curb greenhouse gas emissions and provide finance for both, agreed at the COP26 United Nations climate conference in Glasgow last November.

Religious leaders and faith organisations across Scotland have signed a letter requesting a meeting with Mr Sharma to discuss progress.

At COP26, Mr Sharma said the pact was a “fragile win” and that “unless we honour the promises made – to turn the commitments in the Glasgow Climate Pact into action – they will wither on the vine.”

Scottish religious leaders at the COP26 Vigil on 31 October 2021 courtesy of kelvinstudio.co.uk

Representatives of Scottish faith groups are concerned that world developments have diverted attention from COP26 commitments.

United Nations Secretary General, António Guterres, has warned it is “now or never” to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees.

Director of Interfaith Scotland, Dr Maureen Sier said: “The fragile win achieved at COP26 is at grave risk. It is essential that all governments commit to actioning the Glasgow Pact and work together, with others, to ensure a future for all”.

The letter was developed by the COP26 Interfaith Working Group and signed by faith leaders and organisations across Scotland. The COP26 Interfaith Working Group is made up of representatives from Scottish faith groups and organisations working on climate issues. The group is chaired by Interfaith Scotland with Interfaith Glasgow acting as Secretariat.

Chair and Secretariat of the COP26 Interfaith Working Group

The Rt Hon Alok Sharma MP, COP President Designate

Dear Mr Sharma,  

cc Prime Minister Rt Hon Boris Johnson MP and First Minister Rt Hon Nicola Sturgeon MSP

Faith and Belief Communities request meeting in preparation for COP27

We write to ask for a meeting with you to hear what your Presidency has been doing to honour the Glasgow Pact commitments and what progress has been made.

As representatives of faith groups from across Scotland, we were proud to welcome delegates, campaigners, pilgrims and others to COP26.  We joined people of faith from around the globe demanding action to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius.

We are delighted to share with you our report on Faith Communities and COP26 in Glasgow.

We are increasingly concerned that developments around the world since COP26 have diverted attention from the commitments that were made.  The persistence of the Covid pandemic, a terrible war in Ukraine and dramatic energy price rises that are promoting calls for new oil and gas development put these commitments at risk.

You told us at the close of the conference that it was a “fragile win” and that “unless we honour the promises made – to turn the commitments in the Glasgow Climate Pact into action – they will wither on the vine.”  And UN Secretary General, António Guterres, has warned us it is “now or never” to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees.

We call on you to ensure that the COP26 commitments are put into effect and that climate justice and real energy security are available to all.  As priorities we call upon you to ensure the following:

  • End new oil and gas exploration as recommended by The International Energy Agency
  • Build sustainable economies powered by renewable energy
  • That no one lives in fuel poverty, in the UK or overseas.

As representatives of faith groups across Scotland we commit to doing our part.  Many of us are working across Scotland to promote community action on climate change. We will redouble our efforts and assure you of our continuing support to ensure the commitments made at COP26 are put into effect.

Yours, in hope,

The COP 26 Interfaith Working Group and Scottish religious leaders

The Right Rev Dr Iain Greenshields, Moderator of the General Assembly, The Church of Scotland
Sheikh Hassan Rabbani, Chair of Scottish Muslim Forum
Acharya Ji Mishra, Priest of Hindu Mandir Glasgow
Rev Bonnie Evans-Hills, Priest, Scottish Episcopal Church
Revd Paul Whittle, Synod Moderator, National Synod of Scotland, The United Reformed Church
Choje Lama Yeshe Losal Rinpoche, Abbot, Kagyu Samye Ling
Sr Isabel Smyth OBE, Catholic Bishops’ Interreligious Dialogue Committee
Baha’i Community of Scotland
Muslim Council of Scotland
Richard Murray, Chairperson, Eco-Congregation Scotland
Sally Foster-Fulton, Head of Christian Aid Scotland
Alistair Dutton, Director, SCIAF
Ravinder Kaur Nijjar, Chair, Religions for Peace UK Women of Faith Network, Sikh Representative, Scottish Religious Leaders Forum, Advisor, Sikhs in Scotland
Dr Rose Drew, CEO, Interfaith Glasgow
Dr Maureen Sier, Director, Interfaith Scotland
Professor Joe Goldblatt, Chair, Edinburgh Interfaith Association
Olivia Fuchs, Coordinator, Eco Dharma
Robert Harrap, General Director, Soka Gakkai International – UK
Jill Kent, Chair, Justice and Peace Scotland
Elizabeth Allen, Clerk of General Meeting, Quakers in Scotland
Rev Dr Carolyn Kelly, Chaplain, The University of Glasgow
Harjot Singh Kambo, Lead Coordinator Scotland, EcoSikhUK
Jonathan Baxter, Curator, A+E – Pilgrimage for COP26
Sister Mary McClure, Provincial Leader, Sisters of Notre Dame (British Province)
Christine Anderson, Faithful Companions of Jesus
William G Crook, The Order of Interbeing Plum Village Tradition
Aekus Kamboj, Environment Officer, CEMVO Scotland
David Somervell, Member, South Edinburgh Quaker Local Meeting
Mahrukh Adnan Shaukat, Amina Muslim Women’s Resource Centre
The Iona Community
Glasgow Baha’i Community
Brahma Kumaris
Earth Holders Edinburgh
The Scottish Council of Jewish Communities (SCoJeC)

Supporting organisations
Shanon Shah, Director, Faith for the Climate
Fletcher Harper, Executive Director, GreenFaith
Rev Henrik Grape, Co-Chair, Interfaith Liaison Committee (ILC) to the UNFCCC

If rulers are from God

Young climate protesters at the Scottish Parliament 2022

God and Politics

For use with 1 Timothy 2:1-7 or other passages

Meter 8886  e.g. Saffron Walden, Childhood

it is, of course, absurd, to say, or tolerate the saying, that ‘religion and politics don’t mix’, since both are concerned with the good of people and planet.  The Timothy passage can. however, be read in a way which encouraged quietist disengagement.  

This hymn poem disagrees

1) If rulers are from God, it’s plain

they’ll always seek the common good.

So Christians pray, and give support,

where justice is assured.

2)When rulers lie and cheat and steal;

with malice, trample on the weak

then still we pray, protest and vote;

speak out, when called to speak.

3)God, even-handed sends the rain

bright Sun, through leaves; Creation’s fuel.

Our choices have their part to play:

the web of life’s renewal….

4) When rulers act to tend the Earth:

-every transition must be just-

with all good will, our prayers and more

give power and hope and trust.

God writes our names into the sky

A hymn-poem on the ‘reward’ Jesus said was worth rejoicing over, that the names of those who were prepared to go and heal on his command had their ‘names written in Heaven/the Sky. [Luke 10:20 ]

Tune – LM, ideally ‘Church Triumphant’.

The ‘skyness’ of Heaven is part of the experiential dimension of faith, which of course happens within the unified Creation of ‘Heaven and Earth’

Text only:

1)When we are sent,  we travel light

not bearing hatred, malice, spite

we warn, alert, and love is why 

God writes our names into the Sky!

2)When we are partners with the Earth-

Our praise is chorus; deep our mirth,

with those who swim and squirm and fly:

God writes our names into the Sky

3)God loves this world’s diverse delight:

paints puffin’s beak so rainbow bright.

We’re made that way, so can’t deny

God writes our names into the Sky!

4)The Earth is frail;  we’re sent to heal;

the danger to all life is real

with every prayer and act we try

God writes our names into the Sky!